Skip to toolbar
  • Home
  • Browse All
  • Search
  • My History
  • Login
  • Upload
  • Crowdsource
  • More
  • Contact Us
  • Login
  • Register
  • Voting Results
6011
Open/Close Toolbox
    Format: News
    Parent Collection
    • 2000 News Archive
    Recollections
    Add
    no stories yet
    Copyright
    1This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 New Zealand License
    This licence lets you distribute, remix, tweak, and build upon this work, even commercially, as long as you credit us for the original creation. This is the most accommodating of the licences offered, in terms of what you can do with our works licensed under Attribution.
    Tweet this on TwitterShare this on FacebookShare this on LinkedInShare this on TumblrShare this via email
    Tools
    DownloadAdd to My CollectionLike this itemContact us about thisCitation for this item
    Login | Register
    Campus Buildings
    Canterbury Agricultural College
    Life at Lincoln
    Lincoln Campus From Above
    Lincoln Farms
    Lincoln Township
    Lincoln University
    Maps and Plans
    Outdoor Classroom
    Special Events
    Telford Campus
    Campus & Community
    Accolades and Honours
    Alumni International Medal
    Alumni Reunions
    Bledisloe Medal Recipients
    Blues, Golds and Greens Awards
    Environment Address
    Graduation
    Lincoln Medals and Trophies
    Lincoln University LTL Photography Competition
    Lincoln University Medal
    Ngāti Moki Trophy
    Open Day
    Presentations
    Rā Whakamana
    Sir Turi Carroll Lecture Series
    Celebrations & Events
    Class Photographs
    Group Photos
    Notable Alumni
    Recent Staff and Students
    Staff and Student Profiles
    Staff and Students
    People & Portraits
    About Our Research
    Alumni Publications
    CACLIN
    Calendar / Prospectus
    Graduation Programme
    Heritage and Histories
    Landscape Architecture
    Lincoln College Post Office
    Lincoln Envirotown Newsletter
    Lincoln Planning Review
    Lincoln University Art Collection
    Meteorological Data
    News Archive
    Rā Whakamana Programme
    Ron Blackmore Collection
    Roy Edwards Collection
    Publications & Resources
    ANZAC Day
    Canterbury Earthquakes
    Commemoration
    Dedications
    Remembrance
    World War One 1914-1918
    World War Two 1939-1945
    Remembrance & Memorials
    Cricket
    Football
    Hockey
    Rowing
    Rugby
    Skiing
    Sports Day
    Sports Programme
    Students' Executive
    Swimming Sports
    Tennis
    University Choir
    University Clubs
    Sports & Clubs

    Menu

    • Campus & Community
      • Campus Buildings
      • Canterbury Agricultural College
      • Life at Lincoln
      • Lincoln Campus From Above
      • Lincoln Farms
      • Lincoln Township
      • Lincoln University
      • Maps and Plans
      • Outdoor Classroom
      • Special Events
      • Telford Campus
    • Celebrations & Events
      • Accolades and Honours
      • Alumni International Medal
      • Alumni Reunions
      • Bledisloe Medal Recipients
      • Blues, Golds and Greens Awards
      • Environment Address
      • Graduation
      • Lincoln Medals and Trophies
      • Lincoln University LTL Photography Competition
      • Lincoln University Medal
      • Ngāti Moki Trophy
      • Open Day
      • Presentations
      • Rā Whakamana
      • Sir Turi Carroll Lecture Series
    • People & Portraits
      • Class Photographs
      • Group Photos
      • Notable Alumni
      • Recent Staff and Students
      • Staff and Student Profiles
      • Staff and Students
    • Publications & Resources
      • About Our Research
      • Alumni Publications
      • CACLIN
      • Calendar / Prospectus
      • Graduation Programme
      • Heritage and Histories
      • Landscape Architecture
      • Lincoln College Post Office
      • Lincoln Envirotown Newsletter
      • Lincoln Planning Review
      • Lincoln University Art Collection
      • Meteorological Data
      • News Archive
      • Rā Whakamana Programme
      • Ron Blackmore Collection
      • Roy Edwards Collection
    • Remembrance & Memorials
      • ANZAC Day
      • Canterbury Earthquakes
      • Commemoration
      • Dedications
      • Remembrance
      • World War One 1914-1918
      • World War Two 1939-1945
    • Sports & Clubs
      • Cricket
      • Football
      • Hockey
      • Rowing
      • Rugby
      • Skiing
      • Sports Day
      • Sports Programme
      • Students' Executive
      • Swimming Sports
      • Tennis
      • University Choir
      • University Clubs
    Previous: 2 August 2000 New-look national springboard for organics – Lincoln University's Biological Husbandry Unit re-launchedNext: 28 July 2000 Visiting US academic to speak on current scholarship issues2000 News Archive

    2 August 2000 Organic farming – how do you promote it?

    Organic produceOrganic produce
    Date2nd August 2000Lincoln University

     

    If New Zealand is to pursue a future as a major player in organic production, policymakers must first of all understand how farmers make their decision to grow or not grow products organically. What do they see as the ‘positives’ and the ‘negatives’? And are there some content to stay unaware of the possibilities by ignoring organics altogether?

    Rural sociologist Dr John Fairweather of Lincoln University's Agribusiness and Economics Research Unit and colleagues at the University of Otago are working on a major research project Greening Food: industry and social dynamics, funded by the Foundation for Research, Science and Technology. It's a study which has answered the above questions and here Dr Fairweather reports on policy implications:

    Lincoln and Otago universities have a cooperative research programme studying organic exporting and the ‘greening’ of horticulture i.e. its movement towards more sustainable practices.

    Part of the research has led to policy recommendations deriving from two 1996 studies, one of a variety of farmers in Canterbury, the other of kiwifruit growers in the Bay of Plenty. Both studies had the same aim – to understand how farmers made decisions to grow or not to grow products organically. Both included organic and conventional farmers.

    The Canterbury study included 43 farmers (16 organic, 27 conventional) in a sample designed to cover all the main farming types (horticulture, cropping, sheep/beef, dairy and other animals) and level of activity (smallholdings, part-time, full-time). The Bay of Plenty study included 40 farmers (28 Kiwigreen, 12 organic) and was based on random samples taken from lists provided by the NZ Kiwifruit Marketing Board. Kiwigreen is a relatively new production system using some insecticides plus some organic techniques and is a movement towards organic production.

    The research developed decision trees that identified reasons for and constraints against actions, and these provide the basis for policy recommendations – the subject of this article. It is not assumed that policy initiatives are the sole responsibility of government. The focus is on policies that might be pursued by a variety of organisations such as governments, universities, research institutes, promotional agencies, or private companies. In New Zealand, the activity of private companies has been an important factor in supporting organic farming. In addition to providing premiums, these companies have developed technology, campaigned actively to promote organic production, sold the idea to smallholders and new entrants to farming, and offered technical assistance to farmers. The main focus here is on policies that could affect farmers directly, rather than on policies that could affect the context of farming generally, and policies are taken to be inclusive of broad-ranging initiatives that may affect attitudes, technology development and finances. Each is considered in turn.

    Policies to influence attitudes need to provide information about organic farming to farmers who have never considered it or who are satisfied with their present, low input system. These farmers do not have negative views about organic farming and would appear to be easy to persuade. More difficult to persuade are farmers who are satisfied with their present farming system (and who like high yields, and/or tidy appearance) and farmers who are sceptical about either organic farming's technical and economic viability or its sustainability. Part of the attitude change process may involve the need to promote a different view of what is ‘good’ farming and what is ‘tidy’ farming. It may be necessary to promote ‘untidy’ farms as healthy and economic.

    Scepticism about organic farming's viability can be addressed by publishing widely the results of comparative assessments of organic and conventional production. Some farmers are looking for organic crops and they would benefit from receiving comprehensive information about all the organic alternatives.

    Having made these recommendations, it is important to acknowledge that policy focused solely on attitude change may have limited effectiveness because attitude change is notoriously difficult.

    Policies to promote research that develops technical aspects of organic farming will be important in influencing farmers' thinking because of the perceived technical problems of organic production. There is scope for a number of agencies to study, demonstrate, and disseminate techniques to solve the technical problems associated with organic production. For example, many farmers were concerned about weed control. Yet some of the organic farmers said that they had overcome most of the problems associated with this aspect of organic production; for them it was a matter of timely cultivation combined with careful observation and prompt response to emerging weeds. It seems that weed control is possible and that there are new techniques recently developed but these are not as convenient as using chemicals. There is also a need for research on the crop rotations that are viable under organic farming, and a need for a broader range of organic crops, so that completely organic rotations can be used. Another element to technical development is research that would lead to improvements in seed dressing and cleaning technology to allow efficient separation of seeds harvested from grain crops with a high proportion of weed seeds.

    Another technical (and attitudinal) issue preventing adoption of organic techniques is the apparent compatibility of some chemicals with organic production. A popular chemical is Roundup and its apparently benign effect on the soil makes it difficult for conventional farmers to see why it is not environmentally acceptable.

    Another apparently benign traditional practice is the use of super phosphate fertiliser, and some farmers believe that its use is necessary to benefit soil structure and improve humus levels. These examples illustrate the tensions inherent in defining and certifying organic production, a topic not examined in this article.

    Policies that relate to farm finances and profitability of organic farming are also important and could be developed by a variety of agencies. There is a need for careful analysis of the gross margins associated with growing organic products. Some New Zealand research has been conducted of this type and it shows that the best growers of organic crops for Heinz-Wattie can achieve excellent returns, but the lowest returns occurred for organic growers, typically on small farms. Further research is needed to cover a wider range of products and these results need to be widely publicised. This would have the effect of motivating more farmers to grow organic products by appealing to their attraction to premiums or higher valued products. Moreover, it would address the concerns expressed by farmers sceptical of organic farming's financial viability.

    Generally, farmers' view on the economics of organic production showed contrasting positions: some accepted that premiums were available while others denied that organic production is economic. However, very few farmers were aware of gross margin data comparing organic with conventional production for vegetable crops in Canterbury or kiwifruit in the Bay of Plenty. Kiwifruit farmers were aware that there was an organic kiwifruit premium but guessed that it was, on average, $NZ1.00 per tray when it had been $NZ2.21 per tray. Clearly, there is scope for more informed decision-making on this topic. Better awareness of gross margins may encourage some farmers to appreciate the financial benefits of lowered production of organic products that receive a premium.

    Not only is further research on the gross margins of organic crops needed but attention must be given to the role premiums play in encouraging farmers to grow organic products. Export premiums provide a major incentive to farmers. The decision tree has demonstrated that premiums were vital to supporting the development of organic production.

    If the companies offering premiums did not operate in Canterbury and the Bay of Plenty then it is likely that a key element of the decision tree would not be relevant, and most of the organic farmers would be motivated by philosophy, food, and health factors only. Under such conditions, there would be fewer organic farmers.

    Generally, the research indicates that there is considerable potential for the continued development of organic production in New Zealand. While the financial incentives have played a significant role for some farmers there are still other farmers who grow organic production in the absence of premiums. Further, among conventional farmers themselves, there may be a significant proportion who have not fully embraced high input conventional farming systems and would be well placed to convert to organic production.

    Some farmers in this study were not really aware of organic farming: they ignored it rather than rejected it. There were signs that low input or traditional styles of farming are gaining legitimacy and this development could, in time, encourage more farmers to try alternative systems.

    Finally, a significant proportion of full-time farmers in this study had considered organic farming. If ways are found to address the issues of economic and technical viability of organic farming, including farmers' attitudes to change, then a major stumbling block for conventional farmers would be addressed and the conversion to organic farming would occur more quickly.

     

    Ian Collins, Journalist, Lincoln University, Canterbury, New Zealand

    KeywordsOrganic FarmingLast edited by: Katarina KoningspolicyLast edited by: Katarina Konings
    Lincoln University Living Heritage: Tikaka Tuku Iho (17th Oct 2022). 2 August 2000 Organic farming – how do you promote it?. In Website Lincoln University Living Heritage: Tikaka Tuku Iho. Retrieved 8th Feb 2023 20:42, from https://livingheritage.lincoln.ac.nz/nodes/view/6011
    Content on this site is available for reuse | Contact us
    Privacy Policy | Terms of Use
    Content on this site may be subject to Copyright, please contact Lincoln University Living Heritage: Tikaka Tuku Iho before any reuse if you are unsure.
    RECOLLECT is Copyright © 2011-2023 by Recollect Limited | Page rendered in 0.8117 seconds